13 ways to reshape sales compensation plans during a pandemic Amit Jain September 23, 2020

2020 is turning out to be one of the worst years in the recent history with significant impact on the global economic health. The primary reason for this has been restrictions imposed to contain the spread of Corona pandemic while there have also been several localized natural disasters in different geographical areas that has further worsened the situation.

With COVID-19, the sales environment across industries has shifted to virtual selling resulting in a lack of in-person access and physical time. Organizations have tried to take this problem head on and have implemented several digital platforms and channels to continue to engage stakeholders despite of physical restrictions. Managing, motivating, and ensuring remote sales forces are effectively engaged during such a period has become a challenging proposition.

Organizations are actively working towards assessing the level of impact on their business while working towards short-term and long-term measures to adapt to the “new normal”. Incentives make up the significant portion of total compensation and reduced sales due to unforeseen circumstances may see a huge drop in total payout leading to a risk of lack of engagement and attrition of high performers. This has forced sales operations teams to refine their sales performance management approaches which has added a new dimension to overall complexity in variable / sales compensation management. Balance is constantly being sought between fairness to sales reps, budgetary constraints, and revenue performance. Moreover, another level of complexity is arising from the fact that different parts of the countries are following significantly different infection and recovery trajectories resulting in further need of local adjustments.

Sales compensation plan design is already a complex process because of a need to consider several parameters such as geographically diverse business environments, company culture, labor regulations, market constraints and innovation, customer engagement and selling process, level of impact and control on sales, data availability etc. The desired plan adjustments further forces organizations to rethink their IC philosophy without compromising on key plan design principles.

Following are some of the key sales compensation plan design strategies and adjustment ideas organizations can deploy in case of such unforeseen situation to ensure that representatives continue to be motivated and engaged while preparing themselves for future growth. These options can be bundled based on specific needs and can be implemented for results in the short-term as well as long-term basis:

1- Pay Target or Better

Pay target sales compensation to affected sales, service, and support representatives for the most impacted period where-in they are not able to achieve their targets. Organizations can also choose to go beyond and allow high performing reps to earn more if they manage to beat their targets despite prevalent economic turmoil. This reinforces organizations commitment towards outcomes without compromising on their employees’ well-being and keep them motivated and away from any distractions

2- Guarantee / Draws

Pay a fixed % of target sales incentive, guarantee amount or a non-recoverable draw for the impacted period to strike a balance between field motivation and fiscal responsibility. Organizations can also choose to go for recoverable draws where-in incentives are paid upfront and adjusted once sales have picked up. Like “Pay Target”, guarantees and draws instill sense of security and keeps salesforce motivated and away from any distractions

3- Performance Period Adjustment

Increase the performance period timeframe to ensure that the sales representatives get an opportunity to make up for the lost opportunities by putting in additional efforts in the latter part of the performance period. In certain cases, organizations may decide to reduce the performance period to contain the impact within a shorter period

4- Revising Commission Rates & Introduction of Payment Accelerators & Kickers

Organizations can choose to temporarily increase commission rates or positively revising kickers and accelerators (telecom and insurance) to boost sales representatives’ earnings. On the lower side of the spectrum they can choose to remove or ease decelerators to ensure performance earnings are positively reinforced for sales and deals closed during the impacted period

5- Re-balancing KPI metrics & weights

Reviewing KPI weights and balancing them out to align with emerging business needs like an increased focus on customer centricity. Customer centricity and customer success helps organizations and particularly sales representatives to temporarily move away from the product mindset and focus more on customer well-being which in process helps in developing long-term relationships

6- Goal Adjustments

Provide relief by adjusting quotas down to account for activity and market challenges. These adjustments also need to be tracked for future goal setting to ensure that appropriate baseline adjustments are made once business gets back to normal. Organizations can also choose for goal adjustments specifically over guarantees and other direct pay adjustments as these are pro-rated and aligned with actual performance impact at individual level. This also helps from annual computation standpoint as organizations are saved of any true-ups, retro calculations, and plan updates to account for the impacted period

7- MBO type plan

Pay incentives based on specific activities instead of outcomes to keep the engagement high while ensuring that existing relationships are being maintained remotely and sales pipeline being created for the future

8- Team Performance

Explore options of teaming up sales forces across product / business portfolio to encourage and explore cross-selling and up-selling opportunities

9- Relative Performance

Index territory or individual performance within broader impacted area or complete market to factor in local variations as a part of rationalization of performance

10- Payout Curve Modifications

Lower performance threshold or ease out qualifier metrics like past dues, retro collections (manufacturing), removal of penalties (channel distribution) to allow reps to be “in the money” at lower performance levels (know more about payout curve designs)

11- Pay Mix Change

Change pay mix to reduce the proportion of incentives in the total compensation. While this is a complex and long-term solution, organizations can leverage the opportunity of looking at the overall compensation structure and modifying it to align with changing selling environment in the longer term

12- SPIFFs

Give higher leverage to spiffs & seasonal contests. Avoid including peak COVID impacted performance during calculations. This allows reps to make up the lost opportunity cost by cashing in more during festive seasons or seasonal sale spikes

13- Annual Trip/President’s Club

Provide cash out option for annual trip or at least postpone it indefinitely unless situation is more conducive to travel

To summarize, organizations are evaluating the situation based on their product portfolio, selling environment, sales process complexity, and level of impact, and are deploying different adjustment strategies. Organizations are trying to leverage and analyze data across periods to better understand overall impact and utilizing this information to take fair decisions. We do believe that sales incentive plans can be designed to be reasonably stable, motivating and fiscally responsible. There are inherent counteracting pressures between these design principles with significant complexities being added due to such unforeseen situations but with the help of comprehensive data analysis and leveraging market intelligence appropriate steps can be taken which ensures that sales incentive plans continues to be motivating and engaging.
Please feel free to reach out directly to us at amit.jain@incentius.com to know more on how you can leverage our advanced analytical expertise to take data driven decisions and stay ahead of the curve.